Cannot Decide?

I have a dilemma.  I have a paper topic due tomorrow for a persuasion paper, but cannot decide what to write about.  Here are the two topics I cannot decide on.

1. Should attendance be factored into grades for college students?

2. Are the new Wisconsin report cards legit?  Do they serve the practical purpose intended?


Attendance for College
When I enrolled at UW Sheboygan five years ago I had the assumption that attendance was not a factor when it came to final grades.  I thought college was the total opposite of high school, where students come and go as they please, I was wrong.  Don't be mistaken, I do think tracking attendance is a good thing, I am not sure if it should be mandatory?  College is for adults, should adults be allowed to come and go as they please.  I have had some professors that have the rule if you miss class, it is the student's responsibility to get notes and other class materials from another student.  I like this rule, it allows flexibility and accountability for the student.  Many students are involved in athletics and clubs that require a huge time commitment.  Students also have jobs with hours that vary.  Some students take on responsibilities that better themselves, but could also interfere with class time.  On the flip side, attendance is a life issue.  EMPLOYERS REQUIRE ACCOUNTABILITY, PERIOD!!!!   It will be a shell shock for many students when they do move on from college and enter the world of full time employment. I sound like a lecturing parent, but it is true.  Employers require employees to be punctual and ready to to go.  Most college professors gear students for this same practice.  Be on time for class and ready to participate. It seems to me the days of just listening to lectures and taking notes are gone.  Many professors want interaction and face to face feedback.  I know some people who "just show up" for their jobs, and they are difficult to work with, really useless. 

After writing this blog, I would suggest taking attendance and factoring into grades has more benefits.  But, many would probably argue.


New Wisconsin report Cards
The state of Wisconsin has a new report card system.  The new report card now factors in poverty rates and students growth.  Although many these changes are to better the states education and get a better understanding on how to improve, many are not sold.  Many schools that are located in high poverty areas do not hit the achievement requirement score.  But, their students do show a considerable amount of improvement.  Bravo to these teachers, but on paper they are portrayed as not getting the job done.  Many school reputations may suffer with this new plan.   Unfortunately some schools might lose enrollment, which affects budgets and employment.  I would like to read or hear from more sources before I take a side.

Well, if anyone out there is reading this, I am open to suggestions?  Both offer legit arguments for either sides.